Opened 17 months ago

#783 new defect

Incorrect natural=cape recommendation [30326]

Reported by: fgouget Owned by: jocelyn
Priority: major Component: autre
Keywords: Cc:

Description

I got a '30326 - Watch multiple tags' error on node 948783394:

http://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/fr/error/7437693046

ele = 2971.80
ign:latitude = 42.6519591394770003
ign:longitude = 0.2898652561790000
ign:red = Red Geodésica Nacional Convencional (ROI)
is_in = Aragón;Spain;Europe
man_made = survey_point
name = Punta Suelza
note = This is a point from an official geodetic network. Use it as a reference, but do NOT move it.
ref = 17949
source = Instituto Geográfico Nacional
source:ref = ftp://ftp.geodesia.ign.es

The message is issued by plugins/TagFix_MultipleTag_es.py and wants to add the following tags:

natural = cape
place = locality

Nearby there is the node for the natural peak () and Osmose also wants to add the same two tags to it:

http://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/en/error/7437692348

created_by = JOSM
name = Punta Suelza
natural = peak

I'm not sure adding locality makes sense though maybe it does on the natural peak.

However pushing for 'natural = cape' makes no sense at all. A cape is a "prominent, elevated piece of land sticking out into the sea or large lake".

But this peak is way inland so a cape it is not.
So TagFix_MultipleTag_es.py needs to be revised.

Change History (0)

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.